The Teen Tragedy: The Pop Music of Death
On September 30, 1955, famous movie star James Dean crashed his Porsche 550 Spyder on U.S. Route. He was killed by the collision with another car at State Juncture 41. His posthumous fame rose with the release of the popular Rebel Without a Cause (1955), and to this day, Jame Dean, like Marilyn Monroe, became tragic icons of the 1950s. For the next ten years or so, Popular music turned grim: fatal accidents, suicides, murder became the topic for hit songs. This era became known as the Era of Teen Tragedy.
There are many songs to choose from, but I selected the ten that I most like as opposed to the most popular ones. Songs range from the sublime to the ridiculous, so I'll explain a bit about them. But the best way to experience them is to hear them and read the lyrics, because those lyrics, they're from another age where death was the most precious expression of love.
Let's get to our songs.
1. Teen Angel--Mark Dinning (1959)
Teenage couple's car stall on railroad track as train approaches; they get out of the car safely but the girl runs back for the high school ring that he gave her. The ring was still clutched in her hand when they pulled her corpse from the car wreck. Song ends with a burial.2. Tell Laura I Love Her--Ray Peterson (1960)
Youth races his car in a stock-car tournament to win enough money to buy his girl a wedding ring. He crashes and is fatally injured. His final words as they pull him from the burning wreck, "Tell Laura I love her". Song ends with a burial.
3. Strange Things Happen (Laurie)--Dickey Lee (1965)
Boy meets girl at dance, walks her home, lends her his sweater. Leaves her at her door, forgets sweater, returns, and man answers door. Turns out the man's daughter died a year ago this very night. The boy rushes to the graveyard and finds his sweater on her grave. This is more a popular local legend ghost story that has traveled around to many towns and neighborhoods. Not really Teen Tragedy. He did get his sweater back, after all.
4. Patches--Dickey Lee (1962)
This Dickey Lee tackles a true Teen Tragedy. Boy from the rich side of the railroad tracks loves girl from the poor side of the tracks. His parents forbid him from seeing her again. After he doesn't show up to see her for a while, she drowns herself in the river. When he learns of her death, he vows to commit suicide to join her.
5. Running Bear--Johnny Preston (1959)
Thought about excluding this song for its outdated view on Native Americans, but it's such a great Teen Tragedy song, I had to include it.
Boy and girl from different tribes across the river from each other are forbidden from seeing each other. They swim out and meet each other in the middle of the river and drown.
6. Last Kiss--Wayne Cochran (1961)
Teens are in a car crash. He survives; as she dies, she asks for one last kiss. Pretty simple and straightforward. This song has been covered by Pearl Jam and Taylor Swift, thus legitimizing the Teen Tragedy genre. I think.
7. The Water was Red--Johnny Cymbal (1960)
Young teen boy meets young teen girl by the seaside and fall in love. They go for a swim, and a shark kills her. No gory details, just the water was red. The boy retrieves the girl's corpse from the water and sets it gently on the sand. He then grabs a knife, and he kills the shark. The first chorus (the water was red) refers to the girl's death, and the second to the shark's death. The title gives away the story right off. Beach, swim, red water. Ingredients for a Teen Tragedy song.
8. Call Me Lonesome--Arthur Alexander (1962)
Young teen boy at a dance party with his girlfriend sees another man dancing with his girl. He interrupts the dance as the man gets aggressive with his girl, and he is stabbed to death. What makes this Teen Tragedy song different from the others is that the narrator tells the story of his death and the song fades as he dies while he tells the girl that it's all right with him the way he dies.
9. Jimmy Love--Cathy Carroll (1961)
Young woman narrates the story of how she met Jimmy, her fiancee, and describes how they will marry at the chapel. As they walk in stormy rain, lightning hits a tree, and it crashes down and crushes Jimmy to death. She completes her walk to the chapel and vows to love him forever.
9. Oh, Susie Forgive Me--Kenny Karen (1962)
Narrator, young man, describes his reckless driving which results in his driving into a telephone pole, paralyzing his girlfriends legs. The operation to fix her will cost a lot. The youngster robs a store to get the money, but the police arrive and shoot him. As he lays there dying, Susie, his girlfriend, runs up to him, and he says, "Susie, forgive me." So, could she walk or not? The song doesn't explain. I hear there's other versions of this song, but, sorry, no deep dive for me. As Teen Tragedy, please forgive me for including it.
10. The Pickup--Mark Dinning (1962)
Young man has his first date with a girl that he falls in love with instantly, but he is so overwhelmed by his feelings, that he tones down his feelings so as not to scare off the girl. And when he friends make fun of him for acting so lovestruck around the girl, he tells her that he can't see her again. Later that night, she kills herself by jumping off a bridge, and even as his heart is breaking, he keeps up his facade with his friends that she didn't mean anything to him.
Typical man. Such macho bullshit. This was probably my number one favorite from my deep dive into Teen Tragedy Songs.